Skip to main content

Support Guide

Lead Generation

Shared Leads vs. Exclusive Leads: Which Is Better for Contractors?

Exclusive leads are usually better for contractors who want bigger jobs. A shared lead from a site like Angi, HomeAdvisor, or Thumbtack can go to more than one pro, so you race on speed and price. An exclusive lead comes from your own ads with your name on it, so the homeowner already knows who you are.

Updated Nov 20267 min read
  • What shared and exclusive leads are.
  • A side by side comparison table.
  • What the FTC said about HomeAdvisor leads.
  • How to move off shared leads slowly.

Tired of racing other pros?

We run ads with your face and name on them, so the leads are yours. Our team books the estimate.

Are shared leads or exclusive leads better?

For most good contractors, exclusive leads are better.

With a shared lead, you are one of a few pros calling the same person. The fastest or cheapest often wins.

With an exclusive lead, the homeowner saw your ad. They saw your face. They asked for you.

Shared leads can still fill gaps. But it is hard to build a business on a lead someone else also bought.

What is the difference between shared and exclusive leads?

A shared lead is a homeowner request sold to more than one business. Sites like Angi, HomeAdvisor, and Thumbtack match homeowners with pros. You pay for leads or for being matched. Rules and prices change, so check each site.

An exclusive lead goes only to you. It comes from your own marketing. Your Facebook and Instagram ads. Your website. Your Google profile. Referrals.

With exclusive leads, you own the whole path. The ad, the message, and the follow-up are all yours.

How do shared and exclusive leads compare?

Shared leads (lead sites)Exclusive leads (your own ads)
Who else gets itOften other pros tooOnly you
What the homeowner knowsThe site's nameYour name and face
How you winCall first, often price lowShow trust, sell value
Job sizeOften small or price shoppedCan aim at bigger jobs
Control of the adThe site controls itYou control it
Brand buildingBuilds the site's brandBuilds your brand
If you stop payingLeads stopLeads slow, but your name stays known
Setup timeFastTakes a few weeks to tune

Every market is different. This is a general comparison, not a promise.

What are the hidden costs of shared leads?

  • Time chasing people who chose someone else

    You call. They already booked. That is time you do not get back.

  • Price pressure

    When four pros call, someone goes low. That drags your price down too.

  • Bad fits

    Some leads are too small, out of area, or just looking. You may still pay for them.

  • No name recognition

    The homeowner remembers the website, not you. Next time, they go back to the site.

  • Stress

    Racing to call back every lead in the middle of a job is hard on you and your crew.

What did the FTC say about HomeAdvisor leads?

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) took action against HomeAdvisor. In 2023, the FTC finalized an order that requires HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million.

The FTC said HomeAdvisor made misleading claims about its leads. That included claims about how likely homeowners were to hire soon.

HomeAdvisor disputed the FTC's claims. The order also bans false or misleading claims about leads going forward.

The lesson is simple. Track every lead you buy. How many turn into real visits? How many turn into paid jobs?

How do you switch from shared leads to exclusive leads?

Do not quit all at once. Lead sites may be paying some bills today.

Start your own ads next to them. Track both for a few months. Count booked jobs and money made, not just leads.

As your own ads start to work, move money over bit by bit.

  • Film yourself on real jobs.
  • Run Facebook and Instagram ads in your areas.
  • Text and call every lead within minutes.
  • Track jobs and revenue from each source.
  • Move budget to what makes the most money.

This is what the Houston Growth Engine does for Houston contractors.

Not sure on budget? Read how much a contractor should spend on ads

FAQs

Is Angi worth it for contractors?
It depends on your trade, area, and how fast you call. Track how many Angi leads become paid jobs. Compare that to other sources.
What is an alternative to HomeAdvisor and Thumbtack?
Your own exclusive leads. Facebook and Instagram ads, Google, your website, and referrals all bring leads that only go to you.
Are exclusive leads more expensive?
Sometimes each lead costs more. But if more of them turn into bigger jobs, the cost per job can be lower. Judge by jobs, not leads.
How fast do exclusive leads start?
Ads can start in days. Tuning them to bring good jobs usually takes a few weeks.
Should I stop using lead sites right away?
No. Run both and track results. Move money over as your own ads prove they work.

Want leads that are only yours?

Let's look at what you get from lead sites now and what your own ads could do instead.

Ready for More Calls and More Booked Jobs?

Book a free call. We'll tell you straight if we can help.

  • 100% Free
  • No Pressure
  • Houston-Based